{"links":{"self":"https://petitions.senedd.wales/petitions/247198.json"},"data":{"type":"petition","id":247198,"attributes":{"action":"Review the rules governing restrictions on elected Members speaking in the Senedd","background":"Joe Martin MS asked about demographic change, birth rates and a prediction that white British people could become a minority by 2063. The Llywydd ruled his remarks discriminatory and barred him from speaking in the chamber until he apologises. This raises concerns about possible abuse of authority to stifle legitimate debate and leave constituents unheard. What safeguards prevent the misuse of such powers?","additional_details":"We call on the Senedd to review Standing Order 13.9 and the power to restrict elected Members from speaking.\r\n\r\nFollowing the decision on 10 Nov 2026 to prevent Joe Martin MS speaking in the chamber until he apologises, concerns have arisen about possible abuse of power to stifle debate and deny constituents a voice.\r\n\r\nRespectful debate and protection from discrimination matter. But controversial questions on immigration, demographic change and public policy must remain open to democratic scrutiny.\r\n\r\nWe ask the Senedd to establish clear, proportionate and transparent criteria for speaking restrictions, an independent review process and safeguards against misuse of the Presiding Officer's authority.\r\n\r\nParliamentary standards must not become a means of silencing elected representatives or shutting down legitimate public concerns.","state":"open","signature_count":6,"paper_signature_count":0,"threshold_for_referral":250,"threshold_for_debate":10000,"created_at":"2026-11-11T19:26:49.172Z","updated_at":"2026-11-19T16:00:02.489Z","rejected_at":null,"opened_at":"2026-11-19T16:00:02.469Z","closed_at":"2027-05-19T22:59:59.999Z","completed_at":null,"moderation_threshold_reached_at":"2026-11-11T21:06:20.000Z","referral_threshold_reached_at":null,"referred_at":null,"debate_threshold_reached_at":null,"scheduled_debate_date":null,"debate_outcome_at":null,"archived_at":null,"submitted_on_paper":false,"submitted_on":null,"creator_name":"Kalvin Bird","rejection":null,"debate":null,"topics":[{"code":"constitution","name":"Constitution"}],"signatures_by_country":[{"name":"Wales","code":"GB-WLS","signature_count":6}],"signatures_by_constituency":[{"id":"W09000051","name":"Brycheiniog Tawe Nedd","signature_count":1},{"id":"W09000060","name":"Pen-y-bont Bro Morgannwg","signature_count":4},{"id":"W09000061","name":"Pontypridd Cynon Merthyr","signature_count":1}],"signatures_by_region":[]}}}