Rejected petition Enforce Welsh Government Standards on all NHS Wales Car Park Operators
We petition Senedd Cymru to ensure the Welsh Government enforces its own car parking guidance (WHC (2018) 011) on all private firms contracted by NHS Health Boards. Welsh policy states hospital parking should be free, with proportionate, non-profit enforcement and a compassionate appeals process.
More details
The reality is very different. Patients, visitors, and NHS staff are being aggressively pursued by private firms for minor parking issues. These firms:
• Prioritise profit over patients, incentivising fines and turning hospital car parks into 'cash cows'.
• Operate without transparency—Health Boards refuse to disclose revenue from fines, citing "commercial interests" (e.g., Cardiff & Vale UHB FOI Ref: 24/339).
• Run inhumane appeal systems—initial appeals are designed to fail, causing stress and forcing vulnerable people to pay or face escalating debt.
This is a failure of oversight that allows private companies to profit from the sick, the vulnerable, and NHS staff.
We call for:
• Full transparency on all revenue from PCNs on NHS Wales property.
• A mandate that all Health Board contracts enforce the Welsh Government's guidance.
• A simple, NHS-led first-stage appeals process to prevent templated rejections of genuine cases.
Why was this petition rejected?
It did not collect enough signatures to be referred to the Petitions Committee.
Petitions need to receive at least 250 signatures before they can be considered in the Senedd.
We only reject petitions that don’t meet the petition standards
Rejected petitions are published in the language in which they were submitted