Rejected petition Publish the evidence and legal justification for major public decisions and spending

Council tax has been rising, yet we are increasingly concerned about how major decisions are being taken in our name and with our money. Through official info requests, residents have asked councils and Welsh Government to provide the evidence used to justify decisions affecting housing, waiting lists, planning, the environment, animals, and public data systems. That evidence has not been fully provided, leaving us unable to understand how decisions were justified or whether they were lawful

More details

We are asking councils and Welsh Government to justify the declaration of a “climate emergency”, claims of a housing crisis, large-scale public spending, environmental and wildlife interventions, and the introduction of Digital Data systems. Authorities have failed to provide 'locally specific' evidence demonstrating necessity, proportionality, or lawful justification. Responses often rely on generic or modelled data rather than proof of a local emergency or need. Despite this, these claims are being used to justify major spending, increased housing density, removal of trees and habitats, animal culling, planning changes, and permanent impacts on communities. Many of these decisions are taken by appointed officers using delegated powers, rather than elected councillors.This petition does not oppose housing, environmental protection, or support for vulnerable people.It supports a simple principle: public money cannot be spent, communities cannot be changed, and nature cannot be harmed without evidence, consent, and accountability under the law.

Why was this petition rejected?

It’s not clear what the petition is asking the Senedd or Welsh Government to do. Petitions need to call on the Senedd or Government to take a specific action.

Public authorities already publish lots of detail about decisions, (including impact assessments, and policies) it is unclear what is being asked for in addition.

We only reject petitions that don’t meet the petition standards

Rejected petitions are published in the language in which they were submitted