Rejected petition Restore Joe Martin MS's Right to Speak in the Senedd
Voters in Caerdydd Penarth elected Mr Martin to represent them. Under the ban, he cannot speak for them in debates or questions unless he first apologises. We think that takes away the voice of his constituents, not just his own.
We ask the Senedd to restore his right to speak straight away. We also ask it to review how the Llywydd's powers to silence an elected Member are used, so that any future sanction is in proportion and has a clear, fair way to appeal.
More details
In the House of Commons and the Scottish Parliament, the Chair's power to silence an elected member on their own authority is limited. At Holyrood, the Presiding Officer can exclude a member for one sitting day at most. Any longer sanction needs a vote of the whole Parliament. At Westminster, the Speaker can order a member out for the rest of the day, and a longer suspension has to be agreed by the House. In the Senedd, Joe Martin MS has been barred from speaking with no end date, until he apologises. That decision was made by the Llywydd alone, without a vote of Members and with no clear route of appeal. Whatever people think of his remarks, the people of Caerdydd Penarth should not lose their voice in the Chamber through a sanction harsher and less accountable than other UK parliaments allow. We call on the Senedd to lift the ban and to bring its rules on sanctions into line with those of other UK legislature.
Why was this petition rejected?
It’s about something that the Senedd or Welsh Government is not responsible for.
The petition concerns a decision by the Llywydd (Presiding Officer), not a decision by the Senedd or Welsh Government.
We only reject petitions that don’t meet the petition standards
Rejected petitions are published in the language in which they were submitted